Friend2Friend

Scenario: Talk with Dan 

Ineffective Example 

DAN: Hello? 

RUBY: Hey, hey! 

DAN: Hey! Thanks for like, talking to me about stuff. 

RUBY: Dude, literally any time. 

DAN: So, I'm super excited about this theater party, but I'm also, like, pretty nervous. 

RUBY: Don't worry about it! You'll be fine. 

DAN: Uhh, thanks. I'm still worried about it though. I can't really just stop. 

COACH: Sometimes it feels like we're helping when we say something reassuring to a friend. In this case, Dan felt like you were brushing off his feelings. 

RUBY: Uh, have you tried? 

DAN: Yeah! And it didn't really work. And then I tried calling you. And now here we are. (sigh) 

COACH: While it's good to ask questions, next time, try asking an open ended question to help Dan feel more comfortable sharing. 

DAN: I guess I just don't know what it'll be like. 

RUBY: Well, you'll find out when you get there. 

DAN: I mean, what if I get there and everyone is playing some card game that I don't know the rules to, and they all think I'm uncool? Or what if they play songs I don't know, and everyone is singing along but I don't know any of the words? 

COACH: You brushed off Dan's concerns about the party. Next time try addressing his concerns. 

RUBY: C'mon, that stuff's not gonna happen. 

DAN: I mean it might, right? 

COACH: Dan felt like you brushed off his feelings. Instead, try addressing his concerns directly. 

DAN: But seriously, I think the biggest thing is just that I don't know if there's gonna be alcohol there, and dealing with that whole thing. Like, I know not all parties have alcohol, most don't, but what if this one does? I haven't hung out with them outside school before, and I like, don't know what they're into. 

DAN: I just don't know if I wanna drink at the party or not. 

RUBY: Let's talk through what you're thinking. 

DAN: Yeah, okay. 

COACH: It might help Dan open up more if you ask an open ended question. 

DAN: So, one thing is that the seniors are gonna be there. Besides them being obviously cooler than us. 

RUBY: Obviously. 

DAN: They also choose who to cast in the spring showcase, so, if they don't like me, or think I'm weird or something. 

RUBY: You don't think you'll get cast? 

DAN: Right. 

RUBY: I'm sure they're gonna cast people based on like, skills, and not how fun they are at parties. 

DAN: I mean, hopefully, but if they think I'm annoying, they're not gonna want to rehearse with me for months, you know? 

COACH: You brushed off Dan's concerns. Instead, try asking him an open ended question to get more information. 

RUBY: And where does drinking come in? 

DAN: Well, if I don't drink, maybe they'll think I'm a loser or something. Or, if I do drink, I might do something embarrassing, and then they'll think I'm weird. 

COACH: You asked an open ended question, which let Dan express his thoughts. 

RUBY: Who would ever think you're a loser? No way that'd happen! 

DAN: You can't know that for sure, though. 

RUBY: No, but like, why would they? 

DAN: I don't know. I've never had alcohol before. Maybe I'm the kind of drunk person that gets on a table and acts like a chicken, like I just have no idea how I might act. 

COACH: You tried to reassure DAN: but you brushed off his feelings. Instead, you could show understanding. 

RUBY: I've felt the same way before. I just take some deep breaths, and I feel better! 

COACH: You brushed off Dan's feelings by giving advice. Instead, try acknowledging his concerns. 

DAN: (sigh) The whole reason I'm stressed about this in the first place is, like, we haven't talked to my uncle in years, but I remember when I was little, my parents always hated when we would go out as a family cause he would get drunk and embarrass himself. Like, one time he ordered a shot at a restaurant and spilled it, and he literally licked it off the table. The manager had to ask him to leave. 

RUBY: Wow! That's so embarrassing. 

DAN: That's not really the point. The point is that I never want to do anything like that. 

COACH: You tried to show understanding, but Dan felt judged. Instead, you could try recognizing his feelings. 

RUBY: So, you're nervous that if you drink, you might end up acting like your uncle. 

DAN: Yeah, but then also, like, what if drinking makes me cooler, or more fun to talk to or something? 

RUBY: You're already super cool and fun to talk to. 

DAN: Thanks, that's sweet. I just, it still doesn't really feel that way, though, you know? 

COACH: You started to reassure DAN: but he felt like you brushed him off. Instead, try acknowledging his feelings. 

RUBY: Besides, drinking doesn't just instantly make you super cool, you know? It could even make you act significantly less cool. 

DAN: I guess, but also like, what if everyone there is drinking and they think I'm a loser or a buzzkill or something for not doing it? 

RUBY: You could just like, pretend to drink. 

DAN: I guess I could? I still dunno if I like, wanna do that, though. 

RUBY: Right, okay. Sorry. 

COACH: You gave advice. Instead, you could reassure Dan about his feelings. Also, all drinking under the age of 21 is illegal. 

RUBY: Anybody who doesn't like you just because you don't drink isn't worth your time. 

DAN: Yeah, I guess. 

COACH: You stayed positive and addressed Dan's concerns directly. 

RUBY: People who drink don't make good friends anyway. 

DAN: Uh, we both have friends who drink sometimes. Are you saying they're bad friends? 

RUBY: No, of course not! I didn't mean it that way. I just meant, like, anybody who judges you for not drinking isn't worth your time anyway. 

DAN: Oh, okay. Same goes for you, too. That does actually make me feel better. 

COACH: You said something judgmental, which didn't address Dan's feelings. Instead, try showing you understand. 

DAN: So like, I know this girl I have a crush on is gonna be there. 

RUBY: WHO?! Well, TELL ME! 

DAN: Okay, okay! Do you know Janie? Junior, long black ponytail, in band? 

RUBY: With the really colorful socks? 

DAN: Yep, that's her. 

RUBY: Awwww! You guys would be so cute! 

DAN: I know! And I was so nervous that like, maybe she'd be drinking and think I'm uncool if I didn't drink? But honestly, I wouldn't want to date someone who thought that way anyway. 

RUBY: Totally. 

RUBY: People who drink are losers anyway. 

DAN: Um, okay. I don't think so, but whatever. 

COACH: You said something judgmental, which didn't address Dan's feelings. Instead, try asking an open ended question to check in. 

RUBY: Are you feeling better about the party? 

DAN: I guess I'm feeling a little better? I don't know, talking it out has made me realize that I don't really want to drink. Especially not at some party with a bunch of people I barely know. 

RUBY: Yeah, that totally makes sense. And you know you can always hit me up if you wanna talk about this kinda thing again, right? 

DAN: Yeah, I'll keep that in mind. Thanks, Ruby.